Italy opened the defense of its World Cup title with a laborious 1-1 draw against Paraguay Monday. Paraguay took advantage of its first shot on goal to take the lead in the 39th minute. Antolin Alcaraz outjumped 36-year-old Italy captain Fabio Cannavaro and Daniele De Rossi for a header following a free kick from Aureliano Torres, and goalkeeper Gianluigi Buffon had no chance for a save. De Rossi made up for the opening goal by equalizing in the 63rd, sliding in to redirect a corner kick from Simone Pepe. It was a solid start for the AS Roma midfielder, who was suspended for four games during Italy's victorious 2006 run after bloodying the face of United States forward Brian McBride with a sharp elbow. “We deserved to win,” De Rossi said. “We controlled the ball virtually the entire time, but it's not easy against these teams that dream simply of drawing with the world champions. And if you fall behind, it becomes even tougher.” Italy coach Marcello Lippi said the biggest regret “was the result.” “They only approached the goal once and they scored,” Lippi said. Already without injured midfielder Andrea Pirlo, Italy's fortunes took another hit when it lost perhaps its most valuable player – Buffon – after the first half. The 32-year-old goalkeeper was removed in favor of inexperienced backup Federico Marchetti. “During warmup he felt a pain in his back and after the first half he couldn't continue,” Lippi said. “It was a big blow. We lost a substitution that we could have used.” Lippi's side did little to disprove the critics who have labeled the squad as too old to win the title again, with nine players over 30. The Azzurri haven't won since beating Sweden 1-0 in a friendly in November, drawing with Cameroon and Switzerland and losing 2-1 to Mexico in their World Cup warmups. Italy center forward Alberto Gilardino hardly touched the ball and Lippi acknowledged his team needs to attack with more efficiency. Still, Italy can console itself by looking forward to its next match against one of the lowest-ranked teams in the tournament – New Zealand – before closing out play in Group F against an inexperienced Slovakia side. “We can get two victories,” De Rossi said. Paraguay, which managed upset wins over Brazil and Argentina in qualifying, was considered Italy's toughest opponent in the group. “We were very organized and we defended well in the second half. It's a good result for us against an opponent like this,” Paraguay's Argentine coach, Gerardo Martino, said. After a day of often intense rain, the match kicked off under a drizzle, leaving the field slippery. Temperatures stood at 8 degrees Celsius (46 degrees Fahrenheit), but the swirling winds coming off the ocean made it feel colder. Italy started with six players from its 2006 squad in the lineup and a 4-2-3-1 formation, with Gilardino spearheading the attack and Riccardo Montolivo replacing Pirlo. Martino left Roque Santa Cruz of Manchester City on the bench and started with a two-man forward line of Borussia Dortmund teammates Nelson Valdez and Lucas Barrios. Italy was organized from the start, pushing up the right flank with Gianluca Zambrotta and Pepe, but the Azzurri had trouble getting the ball to Gilardino.