Saudi Cultural Week kicks off in Osaka to mark 70 years of Saudi-Japanese ties    Tourism Ministry shuts 10 unlicensed travel agencies in Riyadh    Saudi authorities arrest over 21,000 residency and labor violators in one week    Saudi graduates see record job market entry in 2024    Israeli defense minister boasts destruction of Beit Hanoun amid Gaza offensive    Von der Leyen vows to defend EU interests after Trump announces 30% tariffs    PKK lay down arms in northern Iraq in symbolic disarmament    U.S. judge blocks immigration arrests in Los Angeles over racial profiling claims    CMA approves major reforms to ease investment account access for foreign and local investors    Saudi Arabia reaffirms OPEC+ compliance as June crude supply hits 9.35 million bpd    Riyadh's Creative District to welcome Italy's Istituto Marangoni    France's Lady Liberty artwork goes viral as a new Statue of Liberty could be in the works    Saudi population reaches 35.3 million in 2024, majority under 65    Abdullah Al-Qaisoom wins silver at Asian Youth and Junior Weightlifting Championship    Aubameyang's future at Al Qadsiah in doubt after cryptic post comparing Saudi League strikers    Theo Hernández: Al Hilal can compete with Europe's best    SFDA approves 'Winrevair' for rare pulmonary hypertension treatment    HONOR returns to Esports World Cup as Official Smartphone Partner for 2025 The renewed commitment will see HONOR elevate mobile esports competition with cutting-edge AI technologies and industry-leading hardware    Michael Madsen, actor of 'Kill Bill' and 'Reservoir Dogs' fame, dead at 67    BTS are back: K-pop band confirm new album and tour    Sholay: Bollywood epic roars back to big screen after 50 years with new ending    Ministry launches online booking for slaughterhouses on eve of Eid Al-Adha    Shah Rukh Khan makes Met Gala debut in Sabyasachi    Pakistani star's Bollywood return excites fans and riles far right    Exotic Taif Roses Simulation Performed at Taif Rose Festival    Asian shares mixed Tuesday    Weather Forecast for Tuesday    Saudi Tourism Authority Participates in Arabian Travel Market Exhibition in Dubai    Minister of Industry Announces 50 Investment Opportunities Worth over SAR 96 Billion in Machinery, Equipment Sector    HRH Crown Prince Offers Condolences to Crown Prince of Kuwait on Death of Sheikh Fawaz Salman Abdullah Al-Ali Al-Malek Al-Sabah    HRH Crown Prince Congratulates Santiago Peña on Winning Presidential Election in Paraguay    SDAIA Launches 1st Phase of 'Elevate Program' to Train 1,000 Women on Data, AI    41 Saudi Citizens and 171 Others from Brotherly and Friendly Countries Arrive in Saudi Arabia from Sudan    Saudi Arabia Hosts 1st Meeting of Arab Authorities Controlling Medicines    General Directorate of Narcotics Control Foils Attempt to Smuggle over 5 Million Amphetamine Pills    NAVI Javelins Crowned as Champions of Women's Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CS:GO) Competitions    Saudi Karate Team Wins Four Medals in World Youth League Championship    Third Edition of FIFA Forward Program Kicks off in Riyadh    Evacuated from Sudan, 187 Nationals from Several Countries Arrive in Jeddah    SPA Documents Thajjud Prayer at Prophet's Mosque in Madinah    SFDA Recommends to Test Blood Sugar at Home Two or Three Hours after Meals    SFDA Offers Various Recommendations for Safe Food Frying    SFDA Provides Five Tips for Using Home Blood Pressure Monitor    SFDA: Instant Soup Contains Large Amounts of Salt    Mawani: New shipping service to connect Jubail Commercial Port to 11 global ports    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Delivers Speech to Pilgrims, Citizens, Residents and Muslims around the World    Sheikh Al-Issa in Arafah's Sermon: Allaah Blessed You by Making It Easy for You to Carry out This Obligation. Thus, Ensure Following the Guidance of Your Prophet    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Clinging to a stereotype
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 19 - 04 - 2008

WILL Barack Obama's now famous “bitter” quote turn out to have been a big deal politically? Frankly, I have no idea.
But here's a different question: Was Obama right?
Obama's comments combined assertions about economics, sociology and voting behavior. In each case, his assertion was mostly if not entirely wrong.
Start with the economics. Obama: “You go into these small towns in Pennsylvania and, like a lot of small towns in the Midwest, the jobs have been gone now for 25 years and nothing's replaced them.
And they fell through the Clinton administration, and the Bush administration.”
There are, indeed, towns where the mill closed during the 1980s and nothing has replaced it. But the suggestion that the American heartland suffered equally during the Clinton and Bush years is deeply misleading.
In fact, the Clinton years were very good for working Americans in the Midwest, where real median household income soared before crashing after 2000.
We can argue about how much credit Bill Clinton deserves for that boom. But if I were a Democratic Party elder, I'd urge Obama to stop blurring the distinction between Clinton-era prosperity and Bush-era economic distress.
Next, the sociology: “And it's not surprising then that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren't like them.”
The crucial word here isn't “bitter,” it's “cling.” Does economic hardship drive people to seek solace in firearms, God and xenophobia?
It's true that people in poor states are more likely to attend church regularly than residents of rich states. This might seem to indicate that faith is indeed a response to economic adversity.
But this result largely reflects the fact that Southern states are both church-going and poor; some poor states outside the South, like Maine and Montana, are actually less religious than Connecticut.
Furthermore, within poor states people with low incomes are actually less likely to attend church than those with high incomes. (The correlation runs the opposite way in rich states.)
Overall, none of this suggests that people turn to God out of economic frustration.
Finally, Obama, in later clarifying remarks, declared that the people he's talking about “don't vote on economic issues,” and are motivated instead by things like guns and gay marriage. That's a political theory made famous by Thomas Frank's “What's the Matter With Kansas?” According to this theory, “values” issues lead working-class Americans to act against their own interests by voting Republican. Obama seemed to suggest that's also way they support Hillary Clinton.
I was impressed by Frank's book when it came out. But my Princeton colleague Larry Bartels, who had an Op-Ed in The Times on Thursday, convinced me that Frank was mostly wrong. - The New York Times
In his Op-Ed, Bartels cited data showing that small-town, working-class Americans are actually less likely than affluent metropolitan residents to vote on the basis of religion and social values. Nor have working-class voters trended Republican over time; on the contrary, Democrats do better with these voters now than they did in the 1960s.
It's true that Americans who attend church regularly are more likely to vote Republican. But contrary to the stereotype, this relationship is weak at low incomes but strong among high-income voters.
That is, to the extent that religion helps the Republicans, it's not by convincing the working class to vote against its own interests, but by producing supermajorities among the evangelical affluent.
So why have Republicans won so many elections? In his book, “Unequal Democracy,” Bartels shows that “the shift of the Solid South from Democratic to Republican control in the wake of the civil rights movement” explains all - literally all - of the Republican success story.
Does it matter that Obama has embraced an incorrect theory about what motivates working-class voters?
His campaign certainly hasn't been based on Frank's book, which calls for a renewed focus on economic issues as a way to win back the working class. Indeed, the book concludes with a blistering attack on Democrats who cater to “affluent, white-collar professionals who are liberal on social issues” while “dropping the class language that once distinguished them sharply from Republicans.” Doesn't this sound a bit like the Obama campaign?
Anyway, the important point is that working-class Americans do vote on economic issues - and can be swayed by a politician who offers real answers to their problems.
And one more thing: Let's hope that once Obama is no longer running against someone named Clinton, he'll stop denigrating the very good economic record of the only Democratic administration most Americans remember. — The New York Times __


Clic here to read the story from its source.