Trump picks Pam Bondi as attorney general after Matt Gaetz withdraws    Fake-alcohol deaths highlight SE Asia's methanol problem    Netanyahu attacks ICC war crimes arrest warrants    KSrelief provided over $7bln to support children around the world    Al-Jasser: Saudi Arabia to expand rail network to over 8,000 km    OMODA&JAECOO: Unstoppable global cumulative sales over 360,000 units    Saudi Arabia sees 73.7% rise in investment licenses in Q3 2024    9 erring body care centers shut in Riyadh    20,000 military emblems confiscated in Riyadh    Al-Samaani visits headquarters of Hague Conference on Private International Law    Al Hilal doesn't need extra support to bring new players, CEO says    Fate of Gaetz ethics report uncertain after congressional panel deadlocked    Indian billionaire Gautam Adani indicted in New York on fraud charges    Rafael Nadal: Farewell to the 'King of Clay'    Indonesia shocks Saudi Arabia with 2-0 victory in AFC Asian Qualifiers    Sitting too much linked to heart disease –– even if you work out    Yemeni Orchestra's captivating performances in Riyadh, showcasing shared cultural legacies    Future of Ronaldo's Al Nassr contract remains undecided, says Saudi Pro League CEO    GASTAT report: 45.1% of Saudis are overweight    Denmark's Victoria Kjær Theilvig wins Miss Universe 2024    Order vs. Morality: Lessons from New York's 1977 Blackout    India puts blockbuster Pakistani film on hold    The Vikings and the Islamic world    Filipino pilgrim's incredible evolution from an enemy of Islam to its staunch advocate    Exotic Taif Roses Simulation Performed at Taif Rose Festival    Asian shares mixed Tuesday    Weather Forecast for Tuesday    Saudi Tourism Authority Participates in Arabian Travel Market Exhibition in Dubai    Minister of Industry Announces 50 Investment Opportunities Worth over SAR 96 Billion in Machinery, Equipment Sector    HRH Crown Prince Offers Condolences to Crown Prince of Kuwait on Death of Sheikh Fawaz Salman Abdullah Al-Ali Al-Malek Al-Sabah    HRH Crown Prince Congratulates Santiago Peña on Winning Presidential Election in Paraguay    SDAIA Launches 1st Phase of 'Elevate Program' to Train 1,000 Women on Data, AI    41 Saudi Citizens and 171 Others from Brotherly and Friendly Countries Arrive in Saudi Arabia from Sudan    Saudi Arabia Hosts 1st Meeting of Arab Authorities Controlling Medicines    General Directorate of Narcotics Control Foils Attempt to Smuggle over 5 Million Amphetamine Pills    NAVI Javelins Crowned as Champions of Women's Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CS:GO) Competitions    Saudi Karate Team Wins Four Medals in World Youth League Championship    Third Edition of FIFA Forward Program Kicks off in Riyadh    Evacuated from Sudan, 187 Nationals from Several Countries Arrive in Jeddah    SPA Documents Thajjud Prayer at Prophet's Mosque in Madinah    SFDA Recommends to Test Blood Sugar at Home Two or Three Hours after Meals    SFDA Offers Various Recommendations for Safe Food Frying    SFDA Provides Five Tips for Using Home Blood Pressure Monitor    SFDA: Instant Soup Contains Large Amounts of Salt    Mawani: New shipping service to connect Jubail Commercial Port to 11 global ports    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Delivers Speech to Pilgrims, Citizens, Residents and Muslims around the World    Sheikh Al-Issa in Arafah's Sermon: Allaah Blessed You by Making It Easy for You to Carry out This Obligation. Thus, Ensure Following the Guidance of Your Prophet    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Is India's planned criminal law reform a game-changer?
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 16 - 08 - 2023

Last week, India's government unveiled three new bills in parliament, stating that they would usher in a "significant transformation in our criminal justice system".
The bills are crafted to abolish and replace a trio of criminal laws. The Indian Penal Code and the Indian Evidence Act are antiquated colonial-era laws, while the Code of Criminal Procedure is half a century old. The bills have been referred to a parliamentary committee for further debate. Home Minister Amit Shah says their objective is to "deliver justice, not mere punishment".
India's criminal justice system needs urgent reform: shoddy police investigations often result in catastrophic miscarriages of justice; jails overflow with undertrials and the slow moving courts are clogged with some 50 million cases.
Legal scholars say the bills do contain some significant changes covering a swathe of the justice system.
For one, they bring offenses like terrorism, corruption, mob lynching and organized crime under penal laws. They allow people to register a police complaint in any police station, regardless of the location where the crime took place. They propose video recording of search and seizure operations and increased use of electronic evidence and forensics during investigations. They introduce community service as a new form of punishment. They advocate speedier justice through video trials, and holding trials in the absence of the accused.
Yet, experts are skeptical about how some of these laws will work. Anup Surendranath, a professor of law at Delhi's National Law University, says the manner in which the new offenses — acts endangering sovereignty, organized crime, mob lynching, terrorism, rape by false promise to marry — are drafted "continues to be so vague that it ends up giving the police unreasonably wide powers of arrest". "These vague provisions perpetuate the exercise of police powers in constitutionally unacceptable ways," he says.
For decades, successive governments have used India's colonial-era draconian sedition law against students, journalists, intellectuals, social activists and those critical of authority. The government now claims that it has taken a "historic" decision by repealing the controversial law.
Not quite, say experts. The sedition law has been replaced by another in the new bill which punishes "acts endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity of India". In other words, experts say, this is really an expanded definition of sedition itself. "Sedition should have gone. It has been retained and perhaps also strengthened," says Naveed Mehmood Ahmad, a senior fellow at Vidhi Center for Legal Policy, a Delhi-based think-tank.
Experts point out that the bills overlook certain crucial aspects. Marital rape has not been criminalized despite India having tough laws to deter sexual violence against women. (The Supreme Court is also getting ready to start hearing petitions seeking its criminalization.) Offenses that criminalize speech — including sedition and obscenity — require reconsideration.
Then there's semantics. Mrinal Satish, a professor of criminal law at the Bangalore-based National Law School of India University, suggests that the terminology of "modesty" employed in the code for the offense of "outraging the modesty of a woman" should be taken out. The bills should have also "revisited the offenses relating to religion and blasphemy, some of which are still very vague and ambiguous to even qualify as criminal provisions", according to Ahmad.
Some of the proposals appear to be fuzzy. Ahmad highlights a provision that mandates a minimum sentence of seven years in prison, life imprisonment, or even the death penalty for every individual within a mob — a gathering of five or more people — found guilty of committing murder based on considerations of race, caste, and community.
"I am not sure what is the most appropriate punishment in this case, but certainly not the death penalty. Imagine sentencing a mob of 50 people to death for murder," Ahmad says.
"Also, the bigger problem in these cases is the investigation, the evidence, and the manner in which the trial is conducted. I don't know how useful it is to club this offense with murder when we know that there are social and political factors that may impact these cases. This may need a very different approach — for determining guilt, collecting evidence and investigation."
Experts agree that many of the provisions in the 163-year-old Indian Penal Code are embarrassingly outdated. There's punishment for a thug, and the offense of obscenity is based on the ideas of Victorian morality. "Except removing the reference to thugs and punishment for it, the new bill retains other outdated parts and definitions. Seeking to change an existing law on the ground that it was enacted during the colonial period is not sufficient justification," says Prof Satish.
Moreover, there exist formidable institutional challenges, say experts. For instance, the bills propose that every crime scene must undergo forensic investigation. "But is India's forensic system ready to handle that? Everyone knows it isn't," says Prof Surendranath.
Most experts say the new bills "retain more than 80%" of the 160-year-old Indian Penal Code, drawn up by British historian Thomas Babington Macaulay. Also, the 50-year-old Code of Criminal Procedure, they say, has been updated and amended regularly, including as recently as 2018. "This is not an overhaul," says Prof Surendranath. "The majority of these bills retain exactly the same existing provisions under new names".
Experts say instead of repealing laws and dealing with the massive administrative challenges that would follow them, India could have just amended the existing laws. Countries like Singapore, Malaysia, Sri Lanka and Bhutan are still using the colonial penal code — Singapore recently made amendments to update it and introduce present-day requirements. India also changed and updated its law on sexual violence in 2013. "That would have been the way forward, not what the bills propose to do," says Prof Satish. — BBC


Clic here to read the story from its source.